Cultivating Quiet Confidence: Beyond Fake-It-Till-You-Make-It

Build genuine self-assurance rooted in competence, self-acceptance, and lived values - the foundation of steady confidence.

I designed this image using automated photo editing tools on my website

---

Build real, quiet confidence effectively. Move beyond faking it to cultivate self-assurance based on competence, core values, and self-acceptance.

---

This advice often circulates in boardrooms and over coffee with well-meaning mentors:

“Fake it till you make it.”

For years, I tried to wear that advice like a well-tailored suit.

• I’d puff up my chest before a big presentation.

• I would adopt a power pose in the restroom mirror.

• I spoke with a forced certainty I didn’t feel.

The result? I felt like an impostor.

The suit was always a size too big, the seams threatening to split with every challenging question. It was exhausting.

Faking it often leaves you with a deep-seated sense of exhaustion. It’s a performance, not a state of being. The moment the curtain falls, you’re left with the same gnawing feeling of inadequacy.

True, unshakable confidence—the quiet kind that doesn’t need to shout—isn’t built on a foundation of pretence. A much more honest and sustainable process cultivates it, step by step. This process is the journey from theatrical bravado to the steady hum of inner confidence.

Key Takeaways

• The Flaw of “Faking It”: Understand why performing confidence often backfires, leading to burnout and amplifying impostor syndrome.

• The Three Pillars of Quiet Confidence: Discover how competence, self-acceptance, and living your values create a resilient foundation for self-assurance.

• A Practical Roadmap: Learn actionable steps to build your skills. Practice radical self-acceptance. Align your actions with what truly matters to you.

• Embracing the Process: See how personal growth isn’t a destination but a continuous, imperfect journey of becoming more authentically you.

---

---

The Great Confidence Charade

We live in a culture that often mistakes volume for value. People often perceive the loudest person in the room as the most confident and knowledgeable.

This pressure pushes us towards the “fake it” strategy. We’re instructed to project an image of unwavering certainty. Our inner world still is a sea of questions and doubts.

But this approach has a critical flaw: it severs the connection between our inner self and our outer presentation.

This disconnect fosters the growth of impostor syndrome. You get the promotion. You close the deal. You get the praise. But a little voice whispers, “If they only knew you were making it all up.”

This process does not foster self-assurance; rather, it constructs a false facade. The constant fear of being “found out” creates a low-grade anxiety. This persistent feeling erodes our overall well-being. It also undermines leadership presence.

Quiet confidence, on the other hand, doesn’t need a microphone. It’s an internal state of being. It’s the calm assurance that comes from knowing who you are. It comes from knowing what you’re capable of. It means you can handle what comes next, even if you don’t have all the answers right now.

The First Pillar: Building Real Competence

You can’t fake skill. You can’t pretend your way to being a talented coder, a skilled carpenter, or an effective manager. Lasting confidence is a byproduct of competence. When you know you can do the work, you don’t need to act.

This step seems obvious, yet we often skip it, hoping a mindset hack will be enough. Building competence isn’t about becoming the world’s foremost expert overnight. It’s about a commitment to deliberate practice.

Here’s how to lay this pillar:

• Recognise the Core Skills: What are your core 1–3 skills? If you improved them by 15%, they would make the most significant difference in your role or life. Avoid overstretching yourself. Start small and focused. For me, it was learning how to truly listen in meetings instead of just waiting for my turn to talk.

• Create a Learning Loop: Dedicate specific time to learning and practice. Try reserving a 30-minute block each morning to read about your industry. Take an online course. Alternatively, practice a new communication technique with a trusted colleague. The key is action, not just passive consumption.

• Seek Feedback, Not Praise: Ask questions like, “What’s one thing I can do differently in that presentation?” or “Where do you see a potential blind spot in this project plan?” This type of feedback is invaluable. This feedback is not a judgement of your worth; rather, it serves as a guide for improvement. Each and every piece of constructive feedback you implement contributes to strengthening the foundation of competence.

You wonder if this means you can’t be confident until you’re a master. This is not the case. Confidence comes from being on the path—knowing you are actively and honestly working to become better.

---

---

The Second Pillar: Radical Self-Acceptance

This pillar is often the hardest to build because it requires us to stop fighting with ourselves. Self-acceptance is not about complacency or giving up on personal growth. It’s the practice of acknowledging your reality without judgement.

It’s saying, “I am a work in progress, and that is perfectly okay. I have strengths, and I have weaknesses. I have good days and bad days. My value is not dependent on my performance.“

Consider this: a gardener does not scold a sapling for not being a tree. The gardener accepts the sapling for what it is. They give it what it needs—water, soil, and sunlight. They trust the process of growth. Self-acceptance is a form of internal nurturing.

How to cultivate it:

• Separate Your ‘Who’ from Your ‘Do’: Your actions, successes, and failures are things you do. They are not the entirety of who you are. When you make a mistake, frame it as “I made an error in the report,” not “I am a failure.” This small linguistic shift is powerful.

• Acknowledge Your Inner Critic: That nagging voice of doubt? Give it a name. Mine is “The Auditor.” When the voice starts its monologue about my inadequacies, I can say, “Ah, the Auditor is back. Thank you for your advice, but I can handle this myself.” By personifying the voice, you create distance and reduce its power. It’s just a thought pattern, not a factual truth.

• Celebrate the ‘Good Enough’: Perfectionism is a primary source of self-rejection. We punish ourselves for not meeting an impossible standard. Practice completing tasks to a “good enough” standard and moving on. This process builds trust in your ability to be effective without being flawless.

Self-acceptance is the anchor that keeps your inner confidence steady, even when the external world is stormy.

---

---

The Third Pillar: Living Your Values

Confidence that does not align with your core values lacks substance. You are competent and successful by external measures. Nonetheless, if your work contradicts your values, you will experience a profound and unsettling dissonance.

Living your values means making choices, big and small, that show who you want to be. It’s about integrity — the state of being whole and undivided. When your actions align with your values, you generate a powerful, quiet energy. You no longer need external validation because you are living in a way that feels true to you.

Start by clarifying what matters most:

• Find Your Core Values: What are your non-negotiables? Is it honesty, creativity, community, security, or adventure? Write down your top 3–5 values. This is your personal constitution.

• Conduct a ‘Values Audit’: Look at how you spend your time, money, and energy. Do these allocations show your stated values? If your values align with “community,” but your calendar is filled with solo work, there’s a misalignment. You haven’t spoken to a friend in weeks.

• Make Small, Aligned Choices: You don’t need to quit your job and move to a monastery tomorrow. Start small. If you value “creativity,” block 30 minutes a week to sketch, write, or brainstorm with no agenda. If you value “health,” take a 10-minute walk at lunch. Each aligned action sends a message to your subconscious: I am someone who lives with integrity.

You act in line with your deepest principles. This builds a form of self-respect. It is the fundamental essence of inner confidence. It’s the quiet assurance that you are on the right path, your path.

---

---

Wrapping Up

Building quiet confidence is a journey, not a sprint. It’s a move away from the brittle performance of “faking it” and towards the resilient strength of being genuine. It’s a process that requires patience.

You need the courage to be a beginner. Have the courage to accept your imperfections. Embrace the courage to live a life that is truly your own.

By focusing on these three pillars, you change your approach.

These pillars are building real competence, practicing radical self-acceptance, and living in alignment with your values.

You stop trying to act confident. Instead, you start becoming a quietly confident person.

This type of confidence does not need any external validation or attention. It’s simply there. It is a steady and reliable presence that guides you through challenges. It allows your true leadership presence to emerge.

🌱Beyond Confidence: The Growthenticity Connection

The core ideas explored in this article aren’t just isolated concepts; they deeply resonate with the principles of what I call ‘Growthenticity’:

“The continuous, integrated process of becoming more oneself (authentic). We achieve such growth by leading with questions, learning through action, and growing by embracing uncertainty and imperfection. All of this is fuelled by curiosity.”

Cultivating quiet confidence is a perfect expression of this principle. Moving beyond “fake it till you make it” means choosing to lead with authentic questions.

Ask yourself, “What skills do I truly need to build?” and, “How can I accept myself as I am right now?”

Learning by action constructs the pillar of competence. Stepping into the arena and practicing, even when it’s uncomfortable, is crucial. It necessitates accepting the uncertainty of not possessing all the answers. It also entails embracing the imperfection of constantly evolving.

Curiosity drives you to uncover your potential. It’s not about performing a role you think others expect.

True confidence, then, is not a static trait but the outcome of this dynamic, authentic growth process.

👉 I encourage you to check out my paid Substack offerings at Lead, Learn, Grow. You can further explore concepts like ‘Growthenticity.’ You will also gain access to practical tools and connect with a supportive community. This community focuses on fostering authentic and impactful growth.

Join us as we unpack these ideas and support each other on our journeys.

🌱 Learn more about me and what I offer my free and paid Substack subscribers.🌱

Here is some information about me and how to connect with me on different platforms.

Your Turn

What is one small action you can take this week? Choose a concrete step to build one of the three pillars of quiet confidence. Share your commitment in the comments below. Your journey can inspire others.

Originally published at: https://nomadlearningblog.com on 13th June, 2025

---

Thanks for reading...

If you enjoyed reading my story, please like and share any parts you think other readers would find interesting.

Don’t forget to leave your comments about what you thought of this story.

Consider following me here on Substack and subscribing to my stories.